59 & 61 Butlers Cove RoadEdgartown MAMLS Number 35460

  • Price: $14,500,000
  • Est. Mortgage of $/month
  • 79 Days on Market
$/month over payments
Federal 30-year interest rate: 3.56% last updated on Sep 12, 2019
* All Figures are estimates. Check with your bank or proposed mortgage company for actual interest rates.
This product uses the FRED® API but is not endorsed or certified by the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis.
  • 9Bedrooms
  • 9Bathroom
  • 15.9Acreage
  • 1971Year Built

Driving Directions

Situated on over 15 waterfront acres on the Edgartown Great Pond, you will enjoy breathtaking views in a truly unique and special setting in Herring Creek Farm. The 5,500+ sq ft main house features hardwood floors, exposed wood beams, six bedrooms, a fitness center, great floor plan, an expansive outdoor patio and stunning water views. The recently built chic guest cottage sits privately next door with three bedrooms, three baths, an open kitchen/living space, deck and gorgeous lawn. Both homes take advantage of a winding boardwalk that leads to your private access to the Pond. Herring Creek Farm also provides homeowners with access to the private association barrier beach on the Atlantic Ocean. This is truly a special opportunity to create a waterfront compound to have for generations to come.

Listed by Landvest MV

Contact Hancock Real Estate:

Do not fill in this field:

More Info

Basic Information

  • MLS Number35460
  • List Price$14,500,000
  • Modification Date2019-07-01T16:00:58
  • StatusACT
  • modified2019-07-01T16:28:04
  • Date Listed2019-07-01T16:00:58
  • Other Struct Description3-Bedroom Guest House


  • Flooring TypeHardwood
  • Floor 1 DescriptionFirst floor consists of living room with fireplace, dining room, kitchen and sitting area with fireplace, all with stunning waterviews, large gym/studio with full bath and walk-in closet, tv room, laundry room and 2 powder rooms. There is also 2 bedrooms with private baths and 2 bedrooms that share a bath.
  • Floor 2 DescriptionFirst wing on 2nd floor offers a bedroom suite over the garage with private staircase and the second wing on 2nd floor over the gym/studio offers the master bedroom suite with private stairwell and private balcony overlooking Edgartown Great Pond


  • Update TypeNONE
  • Second DwellingExisting
  • View Count18


  • StateMA
  • StreetButlers Cove Road
  • Building Number59 & 61
  • Location41.35781421565759, -70.54192543029785
  • Latitude41.357814
  • Longitude-70.541925


  • Acreage15.9
  • ParkingCircular Driveway plus 2-Car Garage
  • Outdoor SpacesWater Views, Deck, Garden, Patio, Gym, Beach Access - Association, Beach Access - Private, Covenants
  • Lot Size SqFt692604
  • Yard TypeExpansive water facing yard

Water Body

  • Water ViewYes
  • WaterfrontPondfront



  • Square Feet7102
  • Fireplaces3 ( Living room, Sitting room, Office)
  • Lead PaintUnknown
  • Rooms18
  • Bedrooms9
  • First Floor Beds4
  • Bathroom9
  • Half Bath2
  • Year Built1971
  • Year Renovated2006


  • SewerSeptic
  • WaterWell
  • Heat TypeGas\FHA


  • FurnishedUn-Furnished
  • FeaturesOutdoor Shower
  • Fridge TypeYes
  • Dishwasher TypeYes / 2 Miele
  • Dryer TypeYes
  • Stove TypeYes / 6-burner Thermador gas cook top with 2 Gaggeneau wall ovens
  • TV TypeCable
  • Washer TypeYes
Hancock Real Estate
Hancock Real Estate
Office: 508-645-2544
PO Box 460
Chilmark, MA 02535

Do not fill in this field:

Do not fill in this field:

Do not fill in this field:

Do not fill in this field:

Do not fill in this field:

Do not fill in this field:


Do not fill in this field: